Ice cream with an eye is a surreal and eye-catching treat. This unique dessert is made with a scoop of ice cream pink in color, with and abstract eye placed inside and hearts on it. Ice cream with an eye is often served in a cone or cup, and it can be topped with other toppings such as sprinkles, whipped cream, chocolate sauce, or hearts. Some ice cream shops even offer more elaborate versions of this dessert, such as ice cream with two eyes or ice cream with a green eye. An Ice Cream with Eye Sticker.